Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mike Speriosu's avatar

Oh my god, Paul, this is a wildly beautiful and insightful poem. I just read it twice aloud and I'm a little taken aback. This is what poetry is for. Each stanza is packed with so much wisdom and beauty.

The first two stanzas feel just like being human, I think, if we adjust our perception of time. Between the very mysterious experiences of birth and death, we live a life much like that puff of smoke, a pattern of matter and energy making its way through reality, not really sure why it's here or what it even really is. Ephemeral and constantly changing, that's for sure.

The third stanza almost sounds like the Universe, or God him/her/itself, living an endless dream convincing itself it's made of separate individual consciousnesses (humans and other animals, at the very least). Your lines about being filled with emptiness perfectly capture this for me. What is it I/Me/Us/We are trying to do here? A grand experiment in pain, ego, and sheer joy? I hope we learn something from it. I think being creative is a wonderful step in that direction. Science too, of course. And even the very painful and hateful human endeavors. I hope we learn from them.

Then you name and capitalize the different aspects of time, and I think you're absolutely right. Future is just another dream Present is having. Present gets to have all the real sensory fun.

The last two lines wrap it up gorgeously. It is in our memory that our pain resides. A grapevine doesn't seem to feel most of this existential pain, for lack of a memory like ours. But perhaps that's just being too anthropocentric. A vine's scars tell many tales, hold many memories indeed. Ways it's had to wrap itself around rocks and trees, cut and bitten here and there, then hardened into wood in the very shape of its injuries, still present and alive, for now.

Expand full comment
Paul Wittenberger's avatar

Thank you for restacking, @Chen Rafaeli

Expand full comment
61 more comments...

No posts